top of page

Why General Violence Reports Were Not Enough for CAT Protection: K-Y-V-R-

2 hours ago
3 min read

General country reports can support a Convention Against Torture (CAT) claim, but they do not replace proof of the applicant’s own future risk. In Matter of K-Y-V-R-, 30 I&N Dec. 203 (BIA 2026), pages 204–205, the BIA found that general gang-violence evidence did not sufficiently establish continuing interest in this applicant or support the prediction that he could not relocate within his country to avoid torture. It therefore vacated CAT protection.


Official first page of Matter of K-Y-V-R-, page 203, showing the September 10, 2026 decision date and October 27 precedent designation


Why past threats did not resolve the future-risk question


The Salvadoran applicant testified that gang members repeatedly tried to recruit him from childhood until he left at age 17. He described threats, rocks thrown at his home, and an assault at school after he refused to join. On January 21, 2020, the immigration judge granted withholding of removal under CAT, relying on those refusals and reports describing gang violence. DHS appealed the CAT grant. See pages 203–204.


The BIA asked more than whether violence existed in El Salvador. It found insufficient support for predicting that the unidentified gang members remained interested in targeting this applicant. He did not testify that they had searched for him since he left in 2015. Nor did the record show that relatives remaining there, or anyone close to him, had since been questioned or targeted. The missing connection was between general conditions and his own future risk. See pages 204–205.


The relocation prediction also needed record support


The immigration judge cited limited education, lack of work experience and a lack of close family ties as difficulties with relocation. The BIA found that reasoning unsupported. The applicant had not tried relocating within El Salvador; although most relatives lived in the United States, he had uncles working as police officers in El Salvador. He was now an able-bodied adult, and the record did not show that he would be prevented from leaving the hometown where he was threatened as a minor and obtaining work elsewhere in the country. The general reports did not support the prediction that relocation could not avoid future torture. See page 205.


This does not make a previous attempt to move a universal prerequisite for CAT protection. 8 C.F.R. §1208.16(c)(3) requires consideration of all relevant evidence of future torture, including past torture, possible relocation to a place where torture is unlikely, serious human-rights abuses and other country information. In this case, relocation concerned the evidence supporting a future-risk prediction; asylum relocation presumptions should not simply be substituted for that CAT analysis.


What the BIA decided—and what it left open


The BIA distinguished factual predictions about what would happen from the legal question whether the anticipated harm would be torture. In this Third Circuit case, it reviewed the former for clear error and the latter de novo. Because the future-risk evidence was dispositive, it did not reach government acquiescence. It sustained DHS’s appeal, vacated CAT protection and ordered removal to El Salvador, without remanding. Asylum and statutory withholding had already been denied; the applicant did not challenge those denials, and the BIA treated the issues as waived. See page 203, footnote 3, and pages 204–206.


The CAT burden is “more likely than not” to suffer torture upon removal. 8 C.F.R. §1208.16(c)(2) also permits credible testimony to satisfy the burden without corroboration. The decision therefore does not require a particular document in every case. Torture must additionally meet 8 C.F.R. §1208.18(a) requirements concerning severe suffering, intent and official infliction, instigation, consent or acquiescence. Leaving acquiescence undecided here did not remove that requirement.


For someone reviewing supporting materials, the decision directs attention to continuing interest by the alleged threat actors, events after departure, and the risks and personal circumstances relevant to relocation. Those are evidence-review questions drawn from the reasoning, rather than a universal document checklist. The BIA decided the case on September 10, 2026; the Attorney General designated it as precedent on October 27 (page 203, footnote 1). As of November 18, 2026, the EOIR Volume 30 index still lists it, and official-source searches found no vacatur or overruling. Application depends on individual evidence, controlling circuit law and later legal developments.


Legal Disclaimer. Originally published: 11/18/2026. This article provides general information only and is not legal advice for any particular matter. Laws, policies, procedures, fees and agency practices may change; their application depends on the facts and jurisdiction. Consult a qualified attorney about your circumstances before acting on this information. Reading this article or contacting Blumsack & Canzano does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. This material may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions.

bottom of page