top of page

Must NIW Research Be Certain to Succeed? Dhanasar | AAO Precedent 07

3 hours ago
4 min read

An NIW petitioner does not have to guarantee a research project’s ultimate success or prove that its chance of ultimate success exceeds fifty percent. Dhanasar instead requires evidence that the person is well positioned to advance the specific endeavor. Uncertainty about research outcomes remains compatible with that inquiry, but the evidence of the person’s qualifications, progress, and support must still meet the preponderance standard. The other NIW requirements remain separate questions.


AAO Precedent Decisions, No. 07 examines Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016). Decided on December 27, 2016, this AAO precedent established the three-prong NIW framework and vacated the earlier NYSDOT framework. Under 8 CFR §103.3(c), designated precedents bind USCIS adjudications involving the same issues, subject to later controlling law and precedent.


First page of the official AAO Dhanasar precedent, showing December 27, 2016, the three NIW holdings, and page 884
Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884. Official decision, first page. Source: U.S. Department of Justice, EOIR; federal government document.

What does the rule about uncertain success actually remove?


Page 890 describes the second prong as being “well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor.” The focus shifts from the endeavor to the individual: education, skills, knowledge, success in similar work, plans for future activities, progress, and interest from potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant parties can all matter.


The same page rejects a requirement that an endeavor be “more likely than not to ultimately succeed.” The AAO recognized that innovations and entrepreneurial efforts may fail partly or entirely despite an intelligent plan and competent execution. Whether a project will ultimately succeed and whether a person is positioned to advance it are distinct evidentiary questions.


The preponderance standard remains. Footnote 8 on page 889 and the discussion on page 890 still require the petitioner to establish the eligibility elements, including the second prong, under that standard. The absence of an ultimate-success requirement does not make an unsupported vision sufficient or turn an unrealized goal into an established fact.


What supported this aerospace researcher’s approval?


The petitioner conducted aerospace research and teaching at North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University and was a postdoctoral researcher when he filed. He held an engineering doctorate and two master’s degrees. His work included computational methods for high-speed air-breathing engines and hypersonic airflow (page 891). The Texas Service Center accepted his advanced-degree professional qualification but denied the NIW under the earlier framework. The AAO reviewed the matter anew under its new framework.


The accepted evidence went beyond degrees. He had developed and validated computational models for high-speed propulsion systems. Detailed expert letters explained why the U.S. government valued his work, and relevant projects received NASA and Air Force Research Laboratory funding. His significant role in funded projects, sustained government support, and peer interest together supported his positioning to advance the research (pages 892–893).


Footnote 11 on page 893 is particularly useful. Although the research center’s director was listed as principal investigator on the grants, the evidence showed that the petitioner initiated several grant applications or was their primary award contact and was the only named researcher on many grants. Those details connected team resources to his own work. The AAO did not describe him as the principal investigator on every project.


Why did the research finding not automatically cover teaching?


The AAO considered his positioning to advance aerospace research together with the research’s value to U.S. strategic interests. In the third-prong balancing, it found a benefit from his contributions even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers were available. It sustained the appeal and approved the petition (pages 893–894).


Teaching received a different analysis. The AAO accepted the substantial merit of STEM teaching but found no showing that his teaching would affect STEM education more broadly. It therefore did not reach the second and third prongs for teaching (page 893). Approval based on research did not establish that every activity of the same petitioner satisfied the NIW test.


How can a researcher use this distinction in an NIW filing?


Separate the underlying classification from the waiver. INA §203(b)(2)(A) and (B)(i) address EB-2 eligibility and the national interest waiver, respectively. Dhanasar requires qualification as an advanced-degree professional or a person of exceptional ability, followed by proof of substantial merit and national importance, the person’s positioning to advance the endeavor, and a balance favoring waiver of the job offer and labor certification requirements. NIW adjudication still involves discretion; satisfying the second prong alone does not compel approval.


The subsequent USCIS policy update issued January 15, 2025 likewise emphasizes underlying EB-2 eligibility and evaluation of evidence in the aggregate, rather than treating any single document as necessarily sufficient. It also addresses support letters and business plans in assessing positioning to advance an endeavor. The evidence in the 2016 case should be understood separately from these later policy requirements.


For researchers, the practical lesson is to build a verifiable connection: what has already been accomplished, how it supports the next research steps, which resources or parties actually support the work, and what the petitioner personally contributes. Project records, funding documentation, and specific expert explanations can corroborate one another. That evidence answers the second-prong question more directly than a promise of success. Government funding carried weight in this record, but Dhanasar did not make it a mandatory document in every NIW petition.


Legal Disclaimer. Originally published: 11/18/2026. This article provides general information only and is not legal advice for any particular matter. Laws, policies, procedures, fees and agency practices may change; their application depends on the facts and jurisdiction. Consult a qualified attorney about your circumstances before acting on this information. Reading this article or contacting Blumsack & Canzano does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. This material may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions.

bottom of page