Can 180 Days Cure a Denied I-140? Al Wazzan | AAO Precedent 06
An I-485 pending for more than 180 days does not automatically turn a denied I-140 into a valid petition. Al Wazzan held that job portability preserves the validity of a qualifying petition; elapsed time cannot replace eligibility review. Current regulations also allow a qualifying I-140 that is still pending when portability is requested to support the request if subsequently approved. A pending petition and an ultimately denied petition are different situations.
AAO Precedent Decisions, No. 06 examines Matter of Al Wazzan, 25 I&N Dec. 359 (AAO 2010). The original decision was entered on January 12, 2005 and designated as precedent on October 20, 2010, with corresponding editorial revisions (page 359, footnote 1). Under 8 CFR §103.3(c), designated precedents bind USCIS in proceedings involving the same issues, subject to later law and precedent.

Why 376 days did not preserve this I-485
The applicant, a Kuwaiti citizen, sought adjustment through the EB-1C multinational manager or executive category. His employer filed two I-140 petitions, both denied. The second was filed on August 26, 2002, followed by the I-485 on September 18, 2002. After obtaining another company’s job offer, he argued that USCIS could no longer deny adjustment once the I-485 had been pending for 180 days (pages 360–363).
A USCIS matching error also affected the record. Footnote 3 on page 361 explains that an early I-485 denial mistakenly linked the application to the first denied I-140. USCIS reopened the matter; the AAO treated the September 29, 2003 denial as effective and calculated 376 days of pendency. The AAO did not resolve the case by denying that 180 days had elapsed. The underlying petition’s eligibility was the problem.
Remaining valid is not automatic approval
INA §204(j), codified at 8 USC §1154(j), provides job flexibility when an adjustment application has been filed and remained unadjudicated for at least 180 days, provided the new job is in the “same or a similar occupational classification.” Both the time requirement and the occupational condition matter. The provision does not create automatic approval when the period ends.
At page 365, the AAO focused on “remain valid”: there must first be validity to preserve. Pages 366–367 connect that language to the eligibility determination under §204(b). Filing and elapsed time cannot substitute for USCIS’s determination of classification eligibility. In Al Wazzan, the underlying I-140 denial was also upheld in a separate decision. Neither the new offer nor 376 days cured that defect. On certification, the AAO affirmed the I-485 denial; it did not approve portability (pages 367–368).
How current rules address a pending I-140
The later employment-based portability rule, effective January 17, 2017, supplies a specific route. Current 8 CFR §245.25(a)(2)(ii) covers both an already approved I-140 and one pending when the beneficiary notifies USCIS of a new job offer at least 180 days after the I-485 filing, if it “is subsequently approved.” Al Wazzan should therefore not be read as requiring every applicant to have I-140 approval in hand before requesting portability.
The pending-petition route has substantive conditions. Section 245.25(a)(2)(ii)(B)(2) requires eligibility for approval at filing and until the I-485 has been pending for 180 days, unless approval at adjudication would conflict with the INA or another applicable statute. That adjudication does not require continuously establishing ability to pay under §204.5(g)(2) until permanent residence is obtained, but other eligibility requirements remain. The regulation also requires 180 days of I-485 pendency, a same or similar job, no revocation of the qualifying approval, and intent to begin the continuing or new employment within a reasonable period after permanent residence is granted (§245.25(a)–(b)).
For someone considering a move, the original I-140 qualifications, I-485 timing, and comparison of the new and original jobs need separate attention. The regulation uses I-485 Supplement J and supporting evidence to demonstrate the continuing or new offer. Al Wazzan rejects the idea that time cures an ineligible petition; current rules preserve a route for a pending petition that later qualifies for approval. Both require examining the petition’s foundation rather than simply counting 180 days.
Legal Disclaimer. Originally published: 11/17/2026. This article provides general information only and is not legal advice for any particular matter. Laws, policies, procedures, fees and agency practices may change; their application depends on the facts and jurisdiction. Consult a qualified attorney about your circumstances before acting on this information. Reading this article or contacting Blumsack & Canzano does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. This material may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions.


