Does a Fictitious Marriage Certificate Trigger INA §204(c)? Christo’s | AAO Precedent 05
A fictitious marriage certificate does not automatically bar a later I-140 petition under INA §204(c). In Christo’s, the beneficiary credibly established that he had never met or married the purported spouse and had neither attempted nor conspired to enter a marriage to evade immigration law. The absence of a wedding, by itself, does not defeat the bar.
AAO Precedent Decisions, No. 05 examines Matter of Christo’s, Inc., 26 I&N Dec. 537 (AAO 2015). The decision was designated as precedent on April 9, 2015. Footnote 1 on page 537 explains that the original decision was entered on August 12, 2013 and later reopened on the AAO’s own motion solely for revisions for precedent designation. Under 8 CFR §103.3(c), designated decisions bind USCIS employees in proceedings involving the same issues unless modified or overruled by later precedent.

Why a cook’s I-140 involved a marriage petition
A restaurant filed an EB-3 I-140 to employ a cook permanently, supported by a Department of Labor-approved Form ETA-750 labor certification used at the time. The Vermont Service Center revoked its earlier approval because the employer had not established the required minimum experience. The AAO initially upheld that ground and independently added the marriage-fraud bar as another reason the petition could not be approved (pages 537–539).
The beneficiary was also named in a separate marriage-based I-130 and concurrently filed I-485. At his Boston interview, he said the marriage certificate was fictitious and that he had never met or married the purported petitioner. With the putative spouse absent and the beneficiary disavowing the marriage, the office denied the I-130 as abandoned and denied adjustment based on misrepresentations concerning that petition.
The service center had raised §204(c) in its notice of intent to revoke but did not include a determination under that section in its final revocation decision. The AAO added that ground on appellate review, initially finding a supported inference of conspiracy to enter a fraudulent marriage. It later reopened the case, permitted a supplemental brief and evidence, and reconsidered both the employment qualifications and the marriage issue.
False documents and conduct toward marriage are separate questions
Current INA §204(c), 8 USC §1154(c) reaches two situations: obtaining or seeking spousal immigrant classification through a marriage determined to have been entered to evade immigration law, and attempting or conspiring to enter a marriage for that purpose. Congress added the second category in 1986. It does not require a completed marriage.
At page 540, Christo’s focuses on the words “entered into” and “attempted or conspired.” Even where false documents suggest an intent to evade immigration law, the inquiry still requires conduct within those statutory categories. A fabricated marriage record alone does not replace that inquiry (pages 540–541).
A critical factual finding appears in footnote 4 on page 541. From the initial interview through his assistance in a USCIS investigation of a person allegedly practicing immigration law without authorization, the beneficiary credibly demonstrated that he had not willfully misrepresented a material fact and had not known that a preparer had done so in benefit requests relating to him. He first learned of the marriage petition when asked about it at the interview, confirmed that he had never met or married the purported petitioner, and identified the certificate as false.
The AAO therefore accepted that no marriage had occurred and that there had been no attempt or conspiracy to enter one, making §204(c) inapplicable. The employer also supplied independent, objective evidence resolving inconsistencies about the cook’s qualifications. It established that he possessed the required education, training, and experience as of the priority date. The AAO sustained the appeal and reinstated I-140 approval (pages 539 and 541).
Ortega later stressed that no wedding is not enough
The BIA’s 2020 precedent, Matter of R.I. Ortega, 28 I&N Dec. 9, calls Christo’s “a narrow decision” at page 15 and distinguishes its facts involving a beneficiary who had never met or married the petitioner. In Ortega, the beneficiary and his fiancée attended two interviews supporting a K-1 petition and maintained that their relationship was genuine. The BIA found a conspiracy to enter a marriage to evade immigration law and upheld revocation of a later family-based petition.
Ortega explains at page 13 that conspiracy under §204(c)(2) requires an agreement to enter a marriage to evade immigration law and an overt act advancing that agreement; a criminal conviction is unnecessary. The petition filing and interview conduct supplied overt acts in that case. The inquiry therefore includes what the parties agreed to, what they did, and whether the beneficiary knowingly participated, rather than stopping at whether a wedding or marriage certificate exists.
Reinstating an I-140 is not granting a green card
Christo’s also separates petition approval from admissibility and adjustment of status. Current INA §212(a)(6)(C)(i), 8 USC §1182(a)(6)(C)(i) addresses obtaining or seeking a visa, other documentation, admission, or another immigration benefit through fraud or willful misrepresentation of a material fact. An erroneous document in the file does not, without examining the required elements, establish that ground.
Pages 540–541 explain that misrepresentations about a nonexistent marriage may still raise inadmissibility issues when an I-485 is adjudicated; the appeal concerned I-140 eligibility. Reinstating that petition’s approval did not grant adjustment or resolve every issue associated with the marriage documents. For an applicant with such a history, the complete earlier record, when the beneficiary learned of the filing, and the beneficiary’s actual conduct are central to understanding the risks for a later petition.
Legal Disclaimer. Originally published: 11/16/2026. This article provides general information only and is not legal advice for any particular matter. Laws, policies, procedures, fees and agency practices may change; their application depends on the facts and jurisdiction. Consult a qualified attorney about your circumstances before acting on this information. Reading this article or contacting Blumsack & Canzano does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. This material may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions.


